Ok, I wasn’t trying to make this post a full-on charge of cultural appropriation. Though the question begs to be asked: When non-Black artists use Black gospel choirs in popular music does it convey levity to their songs? Or as Dave Chapelle would say, “When Keeping It Real Goes Wrong.” Is it blatant swiping of “Black cred” or something else? I also think we should consider the borrowing of “spirituality” by employing a choir.
I want to specify that’s it’s African-Americans who are descendants of slaves that created this music. That’s why listening to other Black artists of different ethnicities and cultures and who hail from other countries aren’t quite able to capture that sound unless they’re trying to imitate it. Why isn’t it considered “cool” and “different” i.e. as VALID when Blacks of different ethnicities collaborate on projects? We’re not all coming from the same place or perspective even if our skin shade is similar.
So I’m going to post some videos because examples are sometimes more effective in conveying a point than mere words. I also thought Paul Simon’s and Peter Gabriel’s use of African musicians on their biggest hit albums as well as Sting adding Cheb Mami for that “exotic” flavor are applicable examples. Actually we can look at Sting’s earlier solo work with his use of Black jazz musicians as if a Marsalis could be considered a mere “sideman”. This conversation should continue as we deconstruct the history of Black musicians not being paid for their work and having copyrights stolen.
What we’re really talking about is an imbalance in power, tilted toward the “white musical genius”. Who’s aiding and abetting these artists? It’s not all racism but also a refusal by many Blacks (in the US) to expand their musical repertoire. The formatting of R&B stations typically excluded numerous Black artists like Lenny Kravitz, Tracy Chapman, Joan Armatrading and others. Why was this tolerated by listeners when they had artists like Teena Marie, Hall & Oates, Queen and others on heavy rotation?
Now there’s one cultural exchange I would not put in this category. There was a genuine collaboration between Shakira and Wyclef for the song “Hips Don’t Lie”, but I wonder if that’s because it was a “woman’s” project and not the other way around?